Starter weirdness
Posted: Mon May 12, 2008 2:52 pm
Strange problem this.
Bike fails to start - no click or whirring when starter is pressed. Bugger, say I. All other electrics work 100%; battery is 1 year old. Seems like a clutch or sidestand switch problem, as the bike had started refusing to start in neutral unless the sidestand was raised. However, yesterday me and a mate checked most of the obvious suspects (clutch switch, sidestand switch, neutral switch circuits) with a multimeter, no problems. Checked all fuses and connectors, all sound.
We decide to try a bumpstart down a gentle slope. For some reason, I'm idly thumbing the starter button and then keep it held down. Just _before_ I actually let the clutch out (building up a little momentum), the engine starts. Idles fine, runs normally. Turn it off and on again immediately and it starts off the button. Repeat a few times, still starts. Turn it off and leave it 10 seconds or so - it doesn't start. Push it along for about 5-10 seconds, holding starter button down and it starts. We try this in neutral, in gear with the clutch in, same result. Seems to work at any speed, as it worked pushing the bike up hill.
So now I have to do pose-y TT style push starts every time I want to ride the TRX. Ho-hum. No good unless I weld a fake kickstart onto the frame and start dressing in black leathers and pudding-bowl lid.
But then I end up buying a Harley and turning into Steve Rose.
Our theory is that the old and non-functional Datatool series 2 alarm in it (long since lost the toggles for it and can't be bothered taking the loom to pieces to remove it) has suddenly decided to activate its immobiliser. Because we seem to recall that these alarms are set up so they can't kill the ignition when the bike is moving (for obvious reasons), we think pushing the bike for a few seconds convinces it to allow the starter to work.
Does anyone (a) think our explanation is crap (well obviously, but give reasons!) and/or (b) have a better explanation?
(Full disclosure - we didn't test the little starter relay thingy (lives under the rear tank hinge, not the starter solenoid), because it seemed to require lots of work and I would just get confused trying to do the test sequence in the Haynes manual.)
Bike fails to start - no click or whirring when starter is pressed. Bugger, say I. All other electrics work 100%; battery is 1 year old. Seems like a clutch or sidestand switch problem, as the bike had started refusing to start in neutral unless the sidestand was raised. However, yesterday me and a mate checked most of the obvious suspects (clutch switch, sidestand switch, neutral switch circuits) with a multimeter, no problems. Checked all fuses and connectors, all sound.
We decide to try a bumpstart down a gentle slope. For some reason, I'm idly thumbing the starter button and then keep it held down. Just _before_ I actually let the clutch out (building up a little momentum), the engine starts. Idles fine, runs normally. Turn it off and on again immediately and it starts off the button. Repeat a few times, still starts. Turn it off and leave it 10 seconds or so - it doesn't start. Push it along for about 5-10 seconds, holding starter button down and it starts. We try this in neutral, in gear with the clutch in, same result. Seems to work at any speed, as it worked pushing the bike up hill.
So now I have to do pose-y TT style push starts every time I want to ride the TRX. Ho-hum. No good unless I weld a fake kickstart onto the frame and start dressing in black leathers and pudding-bowl lid.
Our theory is that the old and non-functional Datatool series 2 alarm in it (long since lost the toggles for it and can't be bothered taking the loom to pieces to remove it) has suddenly decided to activate its immobiliser. Because we seem to recall that these alarms are set up so they can't kill the ignition when the bike is moving (for obvious reasons), we think pushing the bike for a few seconds convinces it to allow the starter to work.
Does anyone (a) think our explanation is crap (well obviously, but give reasons!) and/or (b) have a better explanation?
(Full disclosure - we didn't test the little starter relay thingy (lives under the rear tank hinge, not the starter solenoid), because it seemed to require lots of work and I would just get confused trying to do the test sequence in the Haynes manual.)